"I'm an astrobiologist, and I come from a planetary science background, so in a very broad sense, I s..." — David Grinspoon

What we should really be thinking about is what it would look like for a truly intelligent technological species to be interacting with their planet's atmosphere.

Mars does not have an atmosphere and does not have a magnetic field today, so the planet doesn't have the protection from radiation that our atmosphere and magnetic fields provide us on Earth.

Radiation is one of the important factors in evolution. It causes mutation, and some level of mutation is actually good for evolution.

Earth is going to lose its oceans in the future, just as Venus did in the past. How long planets retain their oceans is a function of distance from the sun, all other things being equal.